Guilty Pleasure #1 (Michael and Sammy)

"Kiss Me" Sixpence None the Richer

"Rhythm of Love" Plain White T's

"Torn" Natalie Imbruglia

"You Don't Know You're Beautiful" One Direction

"We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together" Taylor Swift

"Drops of Jupiter" Train

 

Guilty Pleasure #2 (Tracy)

"Picture" Kid Rock ft. Sheryl Crow

"Before He Cheats" Carrie Underwood

"I Want it That Way" Backstreet Boys

"Seasons of Love" from the musical RENT

 

Guilty Pleasure #3 (Matt)

"Stay" Lisa Loeb

"Adia" Sarah McLachlan

"You Were Meant For Me" Jewel

"Linger" The Cranberries

"Dreams" The Cranberries

"Wonder" Natalie Merchant

 

Guilty Pleasure #4 (Gallagher and Leia)

"MmmBop" Hanson

"That Don't Impress Me Much" Shania Twain

"Celebrity Skin" Hole

"Closer" Nine Inch Nails

"Toxic" Britney Spears

 

Guilty Pleasure #5 (Joyeux)

"Closer to Fine" Indigo Girls

"Faith" George Michael

"Regulate" Warren G and Nate Dogg

"Baby Baby" Amy Grant

"It Must Have Been Love" Roxette

 

Guilty Pleasure #6 (George Lucas)

"Fireflies" Owl City

"Hey Soul Sister" Train